top of page

The Six Weeks

14 hours ago
7 min read

3-Point Summary


  1. Holiday weight gain is smaller than the myth, about a pound on average, but it tends to stay, and it compounds over decades. Heart attacks, arrhythmias, and respiratory infections also rise over the same six weeks.

  2. Celebrating isn't the problem. Extending the celebration is. Give yourself a pass on the holidays themselves, not the eves and not the weeks around them, and run the rest of the season on your normal week.

  3. The real damage happens after the holidays, when the habits carry into February and March. Restore your routine first, then set one or two goals for January.


Three holidays are coming: Thanksgiving, Christmas, and New Year's. Between them sit about six weeks that shape the next year more than most people realize.


The weather gets worse. You're home more. You're surrounded by people, and that includes family. For some people that's the best part of the year. For others it's the hardest. Either way, there's more alcohol and more food that isn't doing you any favors, and a lot of people use both to take the edge off.


December and January are also natural times for reflection. That part of the season gets the least attention, and I'll come back to it at the end.


What the six weeks actually cost


You've probably heard that the average American gains five to ten pounds over the holidays. That number has been repeated for decades, and it isn't true. When researchers at the NIH actually weighed people before, during, and after the season, the average gain was under a pound. Fewer than one in ten people gained more than five. Most people thought they'd gained several times what the scale showed.


That's the good news. The bad news is that the pound didn't come off. A year later it was still there. Adults tend to gain a pound or two a year, and a large share of it appears to happen in these six weeks. One pound is nothing. One pound a year for twenty years is a different body. It works the same way an expense ratio does in a retirement account: small, invisible, and compounding.


Weight isn't the only line item. Heart attacks rise over the holidays. A large Swedish study covering sixteen years of heart attacks found the risk was about 37% higher on Christmas Eve, with a peak around 10 p.m., and elevated again on New Year's Day. Heavy drinking can set off atrial fibrillation, often enough that cardiologists have a name for it: holiday heart. I covered alcohol's full ledger in Risks V. And more time indoors with more people means more respiratory viruses, which was last week's article.


None of that is dramatic on its own. It's several small withdrawals happening at the same time.


Spending, not saving


I think about the holidays the way I think about money. There's saving, there's investing, and there's spending. Spending isn't the enemy. A budget with no room to spend doesn't survive contact with real life, and a holiday season with no room to celebrate doesn't either. Take the time. Be grateful for what you have. Indulge a little.


The problem isn't the spending. It's when a one-day exception becomes a habit because the food and the drinks are sitting right there. Nobody develops chronic sleep deprivation from staying up until midnight on New Year's Eve. Nobody becomes obese from too much turkey on Thanksgiving, and nobody gets cirrhosis from one cup of eggnog on Christmas Eve. The damage comes from extension. The leftovers that last four days. The party season that runs three weeks. The late nights that quietly become the new bedtime.


And it isn't really about the six weeks. The bigger risk is carrying those habits into February and March and digging the hole deeper. December won't wreck your year. December plus a slow January plus a February where you never quite got back on track will.


Write your own rules


I'm a fan of Michael Pollan's Food Rules. The idea is simple. Instead of following a diet, you keep a handful of personal rules about food that you don't have to renegotiate at every meal. The holidays are a good time to write a few of your own.


One of mine is that I have no rules on the holidays themselves. Thanksgiving, Christmas, and New Year's, I eat the meal and have the dessert. Guilt about food on those days doesn't help anyone, and setting a goal you have essentially no chance of meeting isn't discipline. It's a setup.


Unless you're competing in something, and you're probably not, the point of a holiday is to enjoy it. Make it a good day that breaks up the stretch of the year when the weather turns terrible.


The pass applies to the day, though, not the season, and not the day before. Christmas Eve gets a good dinner and the cup of eggnog. It doesn't get a second Christmas. Neither does New Year's Eve. The other forty-some days run on your normal week.


The plan


Before Thanksgiving gets here, write down exactly what you plan to do. Not a holiday diet. Just what the next six weeks look like: which days get a pass, how your training fits around travel, and what you're holding onto no matter what. If you only protect two things, protect regular physical activity and sleep. Most of the rest follows from those.


Then get the food out of the house. Give away as many leftovers as you can, and send people home with containers. If you still have Halloween candy, it's about a month old now. It's time.


If you're going to parties, decide how many drinks you're having before you walk in, not once you're at the bar. Alternating each drink with a glass of water slows the pace without making a production of it. If you plan to drink more than that, plan the ride before you leave the house. A rideshare is cheap compared to every alternative.


When to call, and when not to wait


If you're traveling and you get sick, call us earlier rather than later. We're a concierge practice, and we answer our members on holidays too. Don't sit on a fever until Monday because it's Christmas weekend. Antivirals for flu and COVID work best when they're started in the first few days, and that window doesn't pause for the holidays.


Chest pain is different. If you develop chest pain over the holidays, or at any other time, get evaluated emergently. Call 911 or go to the emergency department. People put it off because they don't want to ruin Christmas. Nobody's Christmas has ever been ruined by a normal workup.


The week nobody plans for


The week between Christmas and New Year's is where routines actually break. Most people are off work, and the week turns into a staycation. What I've noticed over the years is that when people lose their normal structure, their good habits go with it. Nobody decides to stop exercising. The calendar just stops telling them to.


So keep your regular physical activity going that week. Same days, same program. If anything, you have more time for it than usual.


New Year's


The most common mistake I see in January is overcorrection. Someone has a loose December and responds with five new habits, a strict diet, and a training plan they've never done before. It rarely makes it to February.


Avoid aggressive goals. Pick one or two things you want to improve in January and leave it there. The Year in Review piece on December 30 will walk through how to set the rest of the year.


What I actually do


The holiday season has zero impact on my training. I follow the program I already have. I get in, do the work, and leave.


On the holidays themselves, I don't worry much about what I eat, because it isn't going to move the rest of my year. What I pay attention to is the stretch after, because that's the part that does.


If you're in the middle of losing weight


If you're on a weight-loss program right now, it's okay to eat more over the holidays and gain a little back. A planned break from a calorie deficit can be a normal part of a longer weight-loss effort, not a failure of it. The season is stressful and the temptations are everywhere. Don't get too down on a small step backward. Get back to the plan when the holiday is over, not on the next Monday after the next one.


Take stock


Thanksgiving is a good signal to start thinking about next year. Before the new year arrives, ask yourself an honest question: did you make progress over the past twelve months? Not perfection. Progress. Most people who do this exercise find they did better than they would have guessed.


The holidays can also be hard. They bring back people we've lost and loved ones who aren't at the table anymore. If you notice your mood dropping significantly this season, don't wait it out. Call us, or reach out to someone you trust. If you're in crisis, call or text 988, the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.


3 Practical Takeaways


  1. Write the plan before Thanksgiving. Which days get a pass, how you'll train around travel, and the two things you'll protect no matter what. For most people that's exercise and sleep.

  2. Decide before you arrive. Pick the number of drinks before the party, alternate with water, and plan the ride home if you'll go past it.

  3. Don't wait out the serious stuff. If you get sick, call us that day, holiday or not. Chest pain means 911 or the emergency department.



SOURCES


  • Yanovski JA, et al. A prospective study of holiday weight gain. N Engl J Med. 2000;342:861–867. (Holiday gain 0.37 kg; net 0.48 kg by Feb/Mar; not lost by the following fall; <10% gained >5 lb.)

  • NICHD press release, "Holiday Weight Gain Slight, But May Last a Lifetime" (2000).

  • Mohammad MA, et al. Christmas, national holidays, sport events, and time factors as triggers of acute myocardial infarction: SWEDEHEART observational study 1998–2013. BMJ. 2018;363:k4811. (Christmas Eve IRR 1.37, peak ~10 p.m.; New Year's Day elevated; New Year's Eve not.)

  • Ettinger PO, et al. Arrhythmias and the "holiday heart." Am Heart J. 1978. (Origin of the term — verify citation details if you want it named in print.)

Comments


bottom of page